Ontological Modelling

Modelling of four layers:

1. Physical/Historical
2. Textual/Philological
3. Conceptual/Philosophical
4. Argumentation/Logical

• Individuals/Persons (authors, copists)
• Institutions and groups
• Places and times
• Manuscripts (artefacts)

• CIDOC-CRM (https://cidoc-crm.org/)

• Texts (original, copies)
• Texts genres (sophisma, quaestio, disputatio)
• Texts structures (books, chapters, sections, paragraphs, sentences)
• Textual variants ### Existing ontologies
• LRMoo Library Reference Model: https://cidoc-crm.org/lrmoo
• NIE-INE

• internal and cross-references
• concepts such as definitions, distinctions, rules, etc.

• fallacy types and forms
• argumentative patterns and moves
• rules

• CRMInf Argumentation model: https://cidoc-crm.org/crminf

Dummy ontology for Sophismata based on AskSam DB (fincafinfred.csv) which is the source for Ebbesen&Goubier catalogue.

• S = textual content of the Sophisma

  • aut = author
  • titre = work or collection
  • No = number in the collection
  • type = type of Sophisma (families of Sophisma given by their structure) ⇒ See the Catalogue, Vol. 1, p. 13:
    • P = problemata
    • C = corpus only
    • CR = Response
  • syncat = family of syncathegorematic terms (each Sophisma has one, but difficult to identify them ⇒ check Catalogue, Vol. 1, index of problemata divided per synchategoremata)
  • Casus = context of the sophisma [?]
  • sol = standard solution (vs distinction standard SD in the Catalogue)
  • P = [problematic?]
  • structure = notes
  • inc = incipit of the Sophisma
  • expl = explicit of the Sophisma
  • ms = manuscript (usually 1, in the form Paris 15170: 29rA ⇒ Settlement ID: folio)
  • ed = editions
  • lit = literature
  • div = Sten's notes
  • ent = enter date ⇒ to ignore
  • date = nothing ⇒ to ignore